Looking to update your must-eat-at list of metro Atlanta restaurants? Check out these spots, most new to the local dining scene, some old favorites we revisited, that made our list of most highly reviewed restaurants of 2016 and 2017.
Bread & Butterfly: “Oh, but that omelet! Bread & Butterfly serves it at almost any time of the day or night. It is the genuine article, a French omelet, classic in every way.” — Wyatt Williams
290 Elizabeth St., Atlanta. 678-515-4536, bread-and-butterfly.com
Drift Fish House and Oyster Bar: “Drinks, food, service. No wonder the wait time in the main dining room on a Thursday is two hours. Or that the bar and patio are equally packed. Drift is not drifting at all.” — Ligaya Figueras
4475 Roswell Road, Marietta. 770-635-7641, driftoysterbar.com
The Federal: “But, really, let’s talk about that oxtail French onion soup. It is rich and decadent, a deep brown, velvety liquid full of falling apart leaves of onion capped with a thick, broiled slab of Gruyere and crusty bread.” — W.W.
1050 Crescent Ave., Atlanta. 404-343-3857, thefederalatl.com
Murphy’s: “When I take a seat at Murphy’s I am getting a lot for a reasonable price, and far better than any other “neighborhood” restaurant I know. Like I said, I want to move in.” — L.F.
997 Virginia Ave. N.E., Atlanta. 404-872-0904, murphys-atlanta-restaurant.com
Porch Light Latin Kitchen: “It is an impressive accomplishment for a young chef’s first restaurant. Atlantans, take note of chef Andre Gomez. I believe you’ll be talking about him for a long time.” — W.W.
300 Village Green Circle, Smyrna. 678-309-9858, porchlightlatinkitchen.com.
Staplehouse: “The words “with gratitude” are printed at the bottom of the menu. I felt the gratitude — for customers, for fresh food, for exciting cooking, for life.” — L.F.
541 Edgewood Ave., S.E., Atlanta. 404-524-5005, staplehouse.com.
Storico Fresco: “The early bites tend to be simple, indulgent pleasures: a creamy ball of bufala mozzarella and a board of flawless prosciutto, pork meatballs swimming in red gravy and dripping with more bufala, squash blossoms stuffed with ricotta and fried to a light crisp.” — W.W.
3167 Peachtree Road, Atlanta. 404-500-2181, storicofresco.com
101 Steak: “Just as the name suggests, 101 Steak covers the basics. The menu, aside from a few twists, follows the architecture of raw bar and salads, big steaks and rich sides.” — W.W.
3621 Vinings Slope, Vinings. 770-805-8855, 101steakatl.com
Ba Bellies: “There is a youthful attitude in this menu, from silly entree names like Notorious P.I.G. to a beer list that would make any local craft brew geek happy. Most of all, there is that youthful disregard for the old boundaries.” — W.W.
6025 Peachtree Pkwy #9, Peachtree Corners. 770-710-0565, babellies.com/
Beetlecat: “Like a cruise, BeetleCat offers plenty of choices. But the menu needs adjustments to make the trip truly exciting and new.” — L.F.
299 N. Highland Ave. N.E., Atlanta. 678-732-0360, beetlecatatl.com
Brezza Cucina: “On a menu, you might sum that up in three dishes: the gnocchi, the roast chicken, the kale salad. Waxman has been serving some variation of those simple, single-ingredient-focused dishes throughout his career. At Brezza, it isn’t hard to taste why.” — W.W.
75 Ponce De Leon Ave., Atlanta. 404-724-9700, brezzacucina.com
Brush Sushi Izakaya: “Go to Brush Sushi Izakaya, sit at the sushi bar and order the omakase. You will be very pleased. It is as simple as that.” — W.W.
316 Church St., Decatur. 678-949-9412, brushatl.com
Cape Dutch: “Cape Dutch has hits and misses, but those are entirely related to the food menu. Cape Dutch is more than food.” — L.F.
1782 Cheshire Bridge Road N.E., Atlanta. 404-343-0313, capedutchrestaurant.com
Hajime: “There are so many variations, so many of those elements, that getting it all right can feel a little like a Goldilocks quest. Hajime rarely gets everything right all at the same time, but it gets enough right enough of the time, that I find myself continuing to go back.” — W.W.
2345 Cheshire Bridge Road, Atlanta. 470-428-2388, facebook.com/Hajime-1016030255116822/timeline
La Mei Zi: “There’s as much comfort as challenge available at La Mei Zi. You can decide. I’m glad I finally made it to the back of Asian Square.” — W.W.
5150 Buford Highway, Doraville, 770-676-0225, lameiziga.com
The Mercury: “The safest bet at the Mercury is the prime rib sandwich served at lunch. Since it comes on crunchy but tender French bread and melting, paper-thin rings of onion, you’ll never know whether the ribbons of rich beef are a bit dry or not.” — W.W.
675 Ponce de Leon Ave., Atlanta. 404-500-5253, themercuryatl.com
Mezza Luna: “The crowds here bear it out: Sometimes, there’s nothing more satisfying than a big, ugly plate of pasta and a glug of red wine.” — W.W.
1669 Spring Road, Smyrna. 770-319-0333, mezza-luna.net
Nexto: “Thin ribbons of seared wagyu sirloin from Snake River Farms paired excellently with a potent yuzu kosho sauce. A fillet of salmon was seasoned with furikake and cooked to caramelized crisp on the outside, flawless medium rare on the inside. Plated with diced persimmon and toothsome edamame, the dish was a real pleasure.” — W.W.
828 Ralph McGill Blvd., Atlanta. 404-809-3763, nextoatl.com
Noble Fin: “You live intown and already have a go-to place for high-quality fish and seafood? Don’t worry about making the haul out to Peachtree Corners. But neighbors of Noble Fin should check out the new kid on the block.” — L.F.
5260 Peachtree Parkway, Peachtree Corners. 770-599-7979, noblefinrestaurant.com
One Midtown Kitchen: “There’s certainly creativity happening in the kitchen right now as Weinstein and his team give a modern spin to recognizable dishes and aren’t afraid to call on global influences.” — L.F.
559 Dutch Valley Road N.E., Atlanta. 404-892-4111, onemidtownkitchen.com
Rising Son: “In a few years, Rising Son should be as well-worn and comfortable as the classic dishes coming out of the kitchen. Bet on it, this place will be around for a long time.” — W.W.
124 N. Avondale Road, Avondale Estates. 404-600-5297
The Shed: “I think it’s about a chef finding his voice. And I’ll be back to eat up what (Chef Justin) Dixon has to say through food.” — L.F.
475 Bill Kennedy Way S.E., Atlanta. 404-835-4363, theshedatglenwood.com
Ticonderoga Club: “Ticonderoga Club, with all of its fun quirks and explorable food and drink menu, is on the right course. It’s just that the ship is listing slightly.” — L.F.
99 Krog St. N.E., Atlanta. 404-458-4534, ticonderogaclub.com
W.H. Stiles Fish Camp: “The shrimp po’boy, served simply dressed with lettuce, tomato, pickles and a spiked Cajun mayo, is as good as any sandwich Quatrano’s restaurants have ever served. You’ll be happy you got it.” — W.W.
675 Ponce De Leon Ave., Atlanta. 678-235-3929, starprovisions.com/fish-camp.
2016 Atlanta dining scene: Year in Review
The AJC’s dining critics pick their 6 favorite dishes of 2016
6 of the biggest metro Atlanta food stories of 2016
44 dishes from metro Atlanta restaurants that rocked our world in 2016
The Golden Whisk Awards: The best recipes of 2016
10 best Atlanta cocktails of 2016
More Atlanta dining Year in Review